Madison Avenue Pizza
Dunedin, Florida
A Madison Avenue Pizza employee presenting a freshly baked pizza, with a colleague behind the bar

Madison
Avenue Pizza.

New York-style pizza. Ribeye cheesesteaks.
A family-owned pizzeria & full bar in Dunedin.

Order onlineView menu
2660 Bayshore Boulevard
Near Honeymoon Island · Closed Tuesdays

Creative Loafing · Best of the Bay

Best Pizza.
Seven years running.

Readers’ Picks · 2020–2026

Also voted in 2026

Best Philly CheesesteakBest Dunedin RestaurantOur awards & press

“High end, good,
solid pizza.”

Creative Loafing · 2021One of Tampa Bay’s
50 best restaurants.Pizza Today · 2025Featured in
Pizza Destinations.
Explore the stories & videos
Madison’s Angus ribeye cheesesteak on a seeded roll with tots

The cheesesteak

Ribeye. Cooper Sharp.
House-baked bread.

Thin-sliced Angus ribeye and Cooper Sharp on a 10-inch Italian seeded roll, baked fresh in our kitchen every day.

Meet our cheesesteaks

At the restaurant

Bring the family.

Stop in for a slice until 4 pm, bring the family for a whole pie, or catch the game at the full bar. Dine in, carry out, or order delivery throughout Dunedin and most of Palm Harbor.

Our family storyPlan your visit
Two boys enjoying pizza in a booth at Madison Avenue Pizza

The Dough Mobile

Pizza at your next party.

Our fire truck brings the ovens to your event.

Explore catering

Visit Madison

2660 Bayshore
Boulevard.

Dunedin, FL 34698
At Alternate 19 & Curlew, near Honeymoon Island.

DirectionsCall us

Restaurant hours

Sun, Mon, Wed & Thu11 am – 10 pm
Fri & Sat11 am – 11 pm
TuesdayClosed
Delivery hours & more

Bringing a group?

Find large party reservations through Resy.

Find a table

Dine in · Carryout · Delivery
Pizza by the slice until 4 pm.